Some visit links earn us a commission.
Quick verdict
PlushCare is the better pick for most patients on overall scoring. PlushCare is a primary-care telehealth platform that happens to prescribe GLP-1s, not a GLP-1 specialist. That distinction makes it the strongest pick for the insured and the most expensive for everyone else.
That said, Calibrate wins on specific dimensions. Calibrate is a coaching and insurance-navigation program whose value proposition has weakened as direct-to-consumer pricing from Lilly and Novo undercut the 'we'll handle insurance for you' pitch. Cut its fee from $299 to $199 in 2026.
Side-by-side
| PlushCare | Calibrate | |
|---|---|---|
| Starts from | $19.99/mo (+ med separate) | $224/mo (incl. medication) |
| Monthly cost gap | Calibrate is $324/mo cheaper than PlushCare | |
| Lock-in | Month-to-month | 3-mo minimum |
| Time to prescription | 1 day | 14 days |
| Consultation type | Live | Live |
| Affiliate network | Impact | Impact |
Score by dimension
Scores out of 10, equal-weighted across five dimensions. How we score. The winner of each dimension is highlighted.
| PlushCare | Calibrate | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing transparency | 5/10 | 5/10 |
| Cancellation terms | 7/10 | 6/10 |
| Onboarding experience | 9/10 | 4/10 |
| Medication options | 7/10 | 7/10 |
| Member reviews | 6.8/10 | 9.2/10 |
When to choose PlushCare
Best for insurance-covered branded
Patients with commercial insurance that covers Wegovy or Zepbound. PlushCare's PCPs handle prior authorization paperwork well.
PlushCare wins on cancellation terms, onboarding experience on the dimensional scoring. The caveat: Cash-pay patients comparing on monthly cost. The membership + visit fees + cash medication math is rarely competitive against specialists.
When to choose Calibrate
Best for committed behavioral coaching
Patients who specifically want behavioral coaching and have insurance that covers branded GLP-1s. Calibrate's clinicians and coaches handle prior authorization paperwork well.
Calibrate wins on member reviews and runs $324/mo cheaper than PlushCare at the entry tier ($224 vs $548). Over a year that's $3,888 you keep. The caveat: Cash-pay patients. With $597 upfront plus $199/mo plus medication separate, the all-in is rarely under $400/mo. Direct LillyDirect or NovoCare paths beat this on price. Note also: Restructured in 2024 amid demand declines
If cost is your main filter
Calibrate is the cheaper monthly: $224 all-in vs $548 for PlushCare. That's $324 a month or $3,888a year. The 12-month math matters most if you're planning to maintain on GLP-1 long-term. If you're running a 3-month trial, the $972 delta is small against the cost of stopping early on the wrong dose. Insurance changes the picture: if either program runs prior auth and your plan covers Wegovy or Zepbound, branded with copay can beat both cash-pay totals.
If lock-in is your main filter
PlushCare (month-to-month) and Calibrate (3-mo minimum) sit at different cancellation tiers. If you're first-time on a GLP-1 and unsure how you'll tolerate it, PlushCare's easier cancellation is the safer trial.
FAQ
Is PlushCare cheaper than Calibrate?
Can I switch from PlushCare to Calibrate mid-treatment?
Which program has better member feedback?
Read the full reviews
All head-to-head comparisons → · Full chart → · Cost guide · Programs guide
